David stopped Floyd singlehandedly…
-
Archived from the IMDb Discussion Forums — Roger Waters
t_constantijn — 10 years ago(August 24, 2015 10:40 AM)
Doesn't Roger have the right to make a new album under the Floyd name just like David had after the trial
David wasn't even a founding member of the band ,Roger and Syd were.
David joined the band after Syd became psychotic.
I wish Roger would make one last Floyd album ,the real last Floyd album to date was the final cut. IMO -
krypton_son — 10 years ago(September 22, 2015 08:03 AM)
Yeah, I agree, Pink Floyd without Roger Waters just isn't Pink Floyd. Don't get me wrong, David Gilmore is talented as hell, and his solo stuff is pretty good, but to me Pink Floyd will always be Roger Waters.
dies ist meine unterschrift -
Bbonds25 — 10 years ago(September 26, 2015 03:38 PM)
I'm thankful and have been thankful every year since 1994 that Division Bell came out. I hear what you are saying about "true" Floyd. But, i really enjoy DB. Even Momentary had some 16d0really great songs.
-
bigernmc3 — 10 years ago(March 06, 2016 10:27 PM)
You are so STUPID and don't know what your talking about.. My bad, sorry, I disagree with your opinion. DAVID SAVED PINK FLOYD after Syd popped his spring, it was DAVID GILMOUR makes 4 that took FLOYD to that next level it's not one over the other, think of them as one person GILMOUR-WATERS.think of how their vocals trade back and forth in s song so, let's keep it in perspective.. ALSO solo work:
PROS SND CONS OF HITCHICKING
GILMOUR
ABOUT FACEall great work -
lukejbarnett — 3 years ago(August 08, 2022 07:30 AM)
but do you know that david bowie prefers pink floyd with syd to pf after syd?
and its hard to disagree about music when it comes to david bowie.
no, wrong bc i watched a doc on pf and when syd left and david took over they never said david saved pf they said what kept them afloat was roger and his demanding songwriting from the rest of the band well richard and david anyway. so roger saved pf and roger was always the main songwriter after syd.
lukejbarnett