DESERVES BIGGEST PLOT HOLE AWARD!!!!!!!
-
that_writer07 — 14 years ago(October 08, 2011 02:15 PM)
What also annoyed me was the fact that the wife was strapped into that contraption and was bedridden - so couldn't go to the toilet.
So she must have a super bladder which means she doesn't need to go for hours/days on end (remember the beginning when he was due home but was delayed for hours at the hospital with Elizabeth).
But in reality they'd have a full-time nurse with her.
It really annoyed me - just have her with a broke leg not that damn contraption! The scene with the baddie would work just as well with her fumbling to get out of bed and get her crutches. -
taina_39 — 19 years ago(April 01, 2007 05:32 AM)
Also,
I don't get how she could brutally murder that other guy in the mental prison when they say she hasn't eaten for 3 days (correctly me if I'm wrong) and also she's as skinny as a pole and has evident self-mutilation which would if not hinder her in attacking and killing a 6foot probably 170 pound man and completely pwn 5 POLICE OFFICERS.I surrender, Claire's 15. Happy?
-
DeltaNu — 18 years ago(June 07, 2007 04:07 AM)
Well, yes, there were some plot holes in there BUT it was a very good, interesting movie after all. It entertained me and had my full attention during the whole time. What else can someone want???
They showed us several times that the girl saw her Dad put the diamond into that doll, so no mistake there. She also saw that two men put the doll into her Dad's grave and she sat close to the coffin for some time, touching the numbers. That's the last thing she did before he was really gone, so of course she remembered.
And sometimes things seem very clear to one person and just the opposite to many others
As I said, the mistakes didn't bother me at all. And that's not a stupid comment, by the way. One can over-analyze and stop being entertained -
fantasyescapist — 18 years ago(June 20, 2007 05:32 PM)
Saw it on BBC1 - entertaining film. Got confused along the way, like Along Came A Spider, but it was good. I'd give it a 6.5/10.
I think War Of The Worlds(2005) has more plot holes than this, but then again, I missed nearly half of this film,
.
Clark Kent: "I've never seen garbage eat garbage before." -
sasty14 — 18 years ago(July 20, 2007 10:15 PM)
You are freaking retarted! if you wouldve paid attention you wouldve realized that she saw her dad put the diamonds in the doll. The reason the number and diamonds come together is because she buried the doll with the diamonds in her dads coffin, hense the number you tard.
-
ashleydykeman — 18 years ago(September 30, 2007 08:22 AM)
I personally loved this movie, and have watched it more than once. I absolutely adored the girl who played Jesse, and that one kidnapper that was so nice to her. Sean Bean, as always, was amazing, and Brittany Murphy was entertaining and believeable. If I ahd the oppurtunity to watch it right now, I so totally would. I love that movie, and plot holes or not (which by the way, most of them were actually explained in the movie, but you might've missed them) this movie was one of my favourites of 2001.
-
skulk — 18 years ago(October 14, 2007 06:18 PM)
Gary Fleder, in the director commentary, basically admits that sometimes a plot hole is fine as long as the movie keeps moving and keeps the audience interested. He is clearly amused that the last scene, which shows Aggie smiling at Elizabeth even though she doesn't know who she is or that the character even exists, was a reshoot dictated by test audiences that wanted a happier ending. When even the director is making fun of the plot holes, then you know your watching mindless tripe (although enjoyable mindless tripe).
