I can't believe how few threads there are on this board. I haven't seen much, but I am curious how people rate his work.
-
lccmj — 16 years ago(February 03, 2010 08:12 AM)
- 3 Women (1977)
10/10 - Images (1972)
10/10 - Short Cuts (1993)
10/10 - Nashville (1975)
10/10 - MAS*H
10/10 - McCabe and Mrs Miller
10/10 - California Split (1974)
9/10 - The Long Goodbye (1973)
9/10 - The Player (1992)
8/10
"My rule of thumb is, what Siskel and Ebert like, I don't, and vice versa." David Lynch
- 3 Women (1977)
-
flaiky — 15 years ago(November 26, 2010 10:46 AM)
You haven't had a reply to this in a while! Here are my rates so far..
- Nashville - 10
- Short Cuts - 9
- The Long Goodbye - 9
- The Player - 9
- Thieves Like Us - 9
- McCabe and Mrs Miller - 7.5
- MASH - 7
- Gosford Park - 7 (needs rewatch though)
- Cookie's Fortune - 6 (also needs rewatch)
Don't threaten me with a dead fish!
-
silverkid — 15 years ago(January 26, 2011 01:41 PM)
- MASH (1970) / A-
- The Player (1992) / A-
- Short Cuts (1993) / B+
- McCabe & Mrs. Miller (1971) / B+
- The Long Goodbye (1973) / B+
- Gosford Park (2001) / B
- A Prairie Home Companion (2006) / B-
- 3 Women (1977) / C+
- Nashville (1975) / C+
http://most-underrated-movies.blogspot.com/
-
g_monte — 15 years ago(March 10, 2011 01:41 PM)
3 Women
10
(my #2 film of the 1970s)
Nashville
10
The Player
9.5
Short Cuts
9
Gosford Park
9
MASH
9
A Prairie Home Companion
9
McCabe & Mrs. Miller
8.5
The Long Goodbye
8.5
Thieves Like Us
8
Vincent & Theo
8
Secret Honor
8
California Split
8
Cookie's Fortune
7.5
Streamers
7.5
Kansas City
7
Countdown
7
Popeye
7
Images
6.5
A Wedding
6.5
Buffalo Bill and the Indians, or Sitting Bull's History Lesson
6
Come Back to the Five and Dime, Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean
6
The Gingerbread Man
6
Fool for Love
6
Dr T and the Women
6
HealtH
6
A Perfect Couple
5
O.C. and Stiggs
5
The Delinquents
5
Prt--Porter
4.5
Quintet
4.5 -
kinnyhova — 14 years ago(November 03, 2011 04:39 PM)
Mar 6 2010 13:50:58
That Cold Day in the Park (ns)
MAS*H (8/10)
Brewster McCloud (ns)
McCabe & Mrs. Miller (10/10)
Images (4/10)
The Long Goodbye (9/10)
Thieves Like Us (6/10)
California Split (9/10)
Nashville (8/10)
Buffalo Bill & the Indians (9/10)
3 Women (8/10)
A Wedding (5/10)
Quintet (ns)
A Perfect Couple (6/10)
Popeye (4/10)
HEALTH (ns)
Come Back to the Five and Dime, Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean (ns)
Streamers (4/10)
Secret Honor (5/10)
O.C. & Stiggs (5/10)
Fool For Love (ns)
Beyond Therapy (ns)
Vincent & Theo (ns)
The Player (8/10)
Short Cuts (8/10)
Pret-a-Porter (3/10)
Kansas City (6/10)
The Gingerbread Man (ns)
Cookie's Fortune (5/10)
Dr. T & the Women (ns)
Gosford Park (8/10)
A Prairie Home Companion (6/10)
M5b4y favorite director.
McCabe and Long Goodbye are two of my all-timers.
Buffalo Bill is criminally underrated. -
mulholland_empire — 14 years ago(November 25, 2011 11:26 AM)
out of the films ive seen
images 10/10
3 women 9/10
nashville 10/10
short cuts 10/10
the player 9/10
mccabe and mrs miller 9/10
mash 10/10
secret honor 8/10
gosford park 10/10
the long goodby 9/10
one of the most original directors ever. i really wnt to find some more of his 80s films like fool for love and beyond therapy. i will prob break dwn and order them eventually. -
timmy_501 — 14 years ago(February 13, 2012 06:09 PM)
Altman retrospective? Nice.
Images: I thought everything about it was really excellent. The high point for me was the editing. Of course all the illusions are handled really well but there are other big standouts such as the scene in which the woman sees herself going into the house from the mountain and then the perspective shifts to her inside the house. It's a startling moment that helps maintain the film's unsettling atmosphere. Overall it's a nicely surreal film and an interesting stylistic departure for Altman.
This post brought to you by The Yoyodyne Corporation -
timmy_501 — 14 years ago(February 13, 2012 06:51 PM)
I hadn't thought of it that way, I suppose it makes sense since the girl and the woman really seemed to click immediately. I guess I missed the part where it's revealed her father raised her. The part about the girl having a promiscuous mother seemed significant to me, doubly so if I think about it with your interpretation in mind.
This post brought to you by The Yoyodyne Corporation