keanu reeves
-
DrakeStraw — 12 years ago(October 22, 2013 08:10 PM)
Brad Pitt
Did you see Kalifornia (1994)? Brad Pitt played a scumbag serial killer very much like Max Cadyonly worse! Juliette Lewis was also in that one as his nave girlfriend.
My rejects:
Peewee Herman
Will Farrell
Adam Sandler
Jack Black
Arnold Stang
Marvin Kaplan
Billy Barty
Tim Allen
Michael Landon
Take care to whom you REPLYIMDb notification system does not tolerate errors -
Petronius Arbiter II — 13 years ago(January 20, 2013 02:16 PM)
Okay, taking this thread a bit more seriously than was perhaps intended
I disagree with several of these. Not saying that any of the following would have been anywhere near as good as De Niro hell, even Robert Mitchum wasn't as good in the role as De Niro but all of the following, I think, have demonstrated the necessary acting chops to play Max Cady at some point or another in their careers, plus they have (unlike, say, Johnny Depp) a suitable-enough body build:
Robin Williams Has demonstrated at times that he has serious acting talent, even when playing a "dead serious" role quite the opposite of his usual comic roles. For instance, I recall him playing an enraged bereaved husband (or was that a bereaved father whose daughter was killed? foggy memory here) on some TV show or another. I didn't see Mork, I saw the character he was playing.
Ray Romano Something tells me he could have done it, at least when he was in his prime. As with a lot of these guys, it takes some major acting skills to play comedy as brilliantly as they have, and those same skills sometimes translate quite well into serious drama.
Jeremy Piven I'm convinced this guy has a lot more acting talent than most people think he does.
Leslie Nielsen When he was younger, yes.
Rodney Dangerfield Ditto.
Will Ferrell See Piven.
Bill Murray Oh, definitely.
Tom Hanks Can play almost any role.
Brad Pitt Would have to make an effort to bulk up, the same as De Niro did, but definitely has the acting chops.
Charlie Sheen Hey, he's so menacing in
real life
I leave off David Schwimmer only because his face practically screams "Jewish," and just as with the black actors e.g. Eddie Murphy, I can't see bringing ethnicity into it. De Niro could play "intelligent white trash" and make you forget he's Italian-American. Talented as he is, I don't think Schwimmer can make you forget he's Jewish.
Some of the others, like e.g. Brendan Fraser, I leave off because I just don't know enough about them; some who've been listed, I've never even heard of. Some, like Schwarzenegger, I leave off because they're
too
traditionally masculine for the role.
P.S. I would love to see a
Mexican
remake of the 1991 remake, with an all-Mexican cast. Subtitles only, please, I hate dubbing. "Cabo Temor," anybody?
"I don't deduce, I observe."
