Who should play him?
-
JoshAcid — 19 years ago(April 12, 2006 01:18 PM)
Robert Carlyle.
http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.html?id=joshacid37 -
paperline — 14 years ago(February 17, 2012 09:42 PM)
YES! That's who I was looking for, I couldn't put my finger on it. I agree, if he were younger, dyed his hair and lost his accent he would've been perfect for the role. I would also say Adrien Brody just because they have the same sad eyes. For Meryl Streep, Jennifer Ehle who could very well be her younger sister.
-
Reminisce_PartOne — 18 years ago(April 18, 2007 02:34 PM)
Ok this film idea has the potential to be amazing! Spectacular! Touching! A real "tear jerker", anyway just in case big names in the industry ever read boards on this site - "Please somebody make this film very soon, preferably within this decade!"
Anyway, some ideas for actors/actresses to be cast and in which roles:-
As John Cazale- Steve Buscemi - Steve always comes to mind for me. I actually often think to myself that Steve is the John Cazale of his generation (similar acting style, similar voice, similar appearance)
- Elias Koteas
- Paul Giamatti - Great suggestion, however he would have to work on the voice a little (sounds nothing much like John)
- Philip Seymour Hoffman
- Giovanni Ribisi (Would have to get a bit older looking)
- Christian Slater
As Meryl Streep - Julianne Moore (A bit old though, Meryl was in her 20's at the timeJuli is in her 40's)
- Patricia Arquette
- Naomi Watts
- Keira Knightley (Would have to work on an American accent obviously, I think she could pull it off)
As Robert De Niro
Not sure, it's a difficult one can only think of one person:- - Sean Penn (But he's a bit old to play 1970's De Niro, it may have to be 1980's De Nirowhich obviously would not be relevant to the film anyway)
As Al Pacino - Leonardo DiCaprio (Sounds daft I know, but Leo has become one of the most flexible actors of his generation. The appearance could be good with a little work, and Leo is a talented actor)
- John Leguizamo
- Giovanni Ribisi
As Marlon Brando - Robert Duvall
- Robert Vaughn
- James Caan
As James Caan - Leonardo DiCaprio
- Johnny Depp
- Mark Wahlberg
- Philip Seymour Hoffman (Would have to lose some weight)
- Christian Slater
As Robert Duvall - Damian Lewis
- Tim Roth
- Sean Penn
As Francis Ford Coppola - Paul Giamatti
- John C. Reilly
As Diane Keaton - Julianne Moore
- Nicole Kidman
- Sharon Stone (But I find her incredibly annoying, she gives me migranesshe may be adequate however)
- Tea Leoni
As Talia Shire - Valeria Golino
(Not really sure, can't think of much anyone)
As Lee Strasberg - Eli Wallach - It would have to be Eli. Eli is the 2000's version of the 1970's Lee
As Michael V. Gazzo
This one is too difficult for me to call. I can't think of anyone, I loved Michael in the Godfather: Part II but I just can't think of anyone.
As Christopher Walken
CAN'T THINK DAMN IT! TOO TIRED!
As Frederic Forrest - Tom Sizemore
- Philip Seymour Hoffman
I love South Park! Matt and Trey are genius! JR
-
TravisChelios — 18 years ago(April 20, 2007 12:03 PM)
James Caan could be played by Scott Caan
Christopher Walken could be played by William Fitchner
http://www.myspace.com/mickeyduffy -
Reminisce_PartOne — 18 years ago(April 20, 2007 01:47 PM)
Yeah y'know I've been kicking myself for not thinking of Scott Caan to play James Caan! Like duh it's the guys sonI was kinda tired when I posted that message thoughoh and good call on William Fichtner to play Christopher Walken.
I love South Park! Matt and Trey are genius! JR -
TravisChelios — 18 years ago(April 20, 2007 03:45 PM)
Thanks, I think Elias Koteas would be the best out of your Cazale options? Appearance wise anyway and Naomi Watts for5b4 Meryl Streep defo!
Would be a good biopic if it was made! Hopefully it will be some day
http://www.myspace.com/mickeyduffy -
Reminisce_PartOne — 18 years ago(April 21, 2007 03:43 AM)
Yeah I'm surprised I never thought of Elias Koteas until just recently. He looks so much like John Cazale, and he could play him very well I'm 16d0sure.
I love South Park! Matt and Trey are genius! JR -
shani-3 — 15 years ago(July 21, 2010 09:40 AM)
There's this young Broadway actor named James Snyder who really reminds me John Cazale as far as looks; he's actually way more handsome than John, but something about his face (especially the eyesvery important) captures the 'essence' of John(In fact, after seeing rare footage of John 'out of character' in the documentary of his life, he really was oddly handsome). As for Meryl Streep, the perfect actress for the role would be Jennifer Ehle. She is a classic, serene beauty, who has often been compared to Meryl Streep in both looks and talent. In fact, her mother, Rosemary Harris, played Streep's mother-in-law in the miniseries "Holocaust".
Yeah, they're dead, they'reall messed up.